top of page





Low Prices

As one of the key structural components of your house, your roof plays a vital role in keeping your family safe, healthy, and comfortable. Over time, though, wear and tear can allow for roof leaks, enable damage, or degrade your roofing system due to age. Homeowners facing problems with their roofs inevitably arrive at a decision point – whether to repair these specific areas or replace the roof entirely! 


When roof problems appear, there's rarely an obvious or easy choice between fixing them or starting fresh with a new roof. What makes the most sense depends on several unique factors, like how old your current roof is, the level of disrepair you're facing, budget constraints, and even future plans for the home.


Before deciding one way or another, carefully weigh the pros and cons through the lens of your home's distinct needs. This article will break down key considerations around roof repair versus replacement in order to guide you in determining the smartest move for your situation. Feel free to contact Simple Solutions today for more information! 

Things to Consider for Your Home's Next Roofing Project

When weighing roof repair against replacement, several important factors should be considered. Looking closely at key considerations around the roof and your home can steer you toward the savviest long-term solution! Rather than rushing into a quick fix or expensive overhaul, carefully examine variables like roof age, the extent of damage, and your plans for staying in the home or selling in the future. Evaluating your specific scenario guides intelligent, forward-thinking choices on roof work. Remember budget limitations, as repairs or partial fixes may suffice if the damage is minor. However, substantial wear or leaking may require new materials across larger areas or the entire roof plane. The goal is to determine what aligns best for your home's protection and your family's comfort and safety within your financial situation. 

How Old is Your Roofing System?

Compared to its expected lifespan, the current age of your roof plays a big role in deciding whether repair or replacement makes more sense. For example, asphalt shingles used on many American homes typically last around 20 years before showing signs of wear, tear, or aging through exposure to weather. If your roof is getting close to or past that two-decade mark, continuing to patch rather than replace may lead to wasted money on repairs in the long run. 


At a certain point, repairs become stopgap measures that mask more pervasive issues with an aging roof. As the system nears the end of functional use, leaks, moisture damage, and required fixes pop up across shingles well beyond their prime. Constant repairs start to resemble merely putting a bandage on issues that are bound to resurface. Before you know it, you've paid for pricier patchwork but still need to shell out for full replacement sooner than expected! 

What is Your Roof's Current Condition?

Beyond roof age, carefully inspect its current condition inside and out to determine if repairs or full replacement makes more sense for your old roof. 

What Roof Area is Affected by the Damages?

If you have a small area of moderate leaking or damage, roof repairs may be the most sensible and affordable option. Why invest in a new roof when only one place or section needs attention? However, suppose you discover severe water damage, mold growth, rotting rafters, or structural damage spanning large areas of your roof while inspecting. In that case, replacement is likely necessary to prevent further destruction. 

Do You Have a Viable Insurance Claim?

In the case of major wind, hail, storm damage, or fallen tree damage, you may have a viable homeowner's insurance claim to fully replace your roof (minus your deductible). Consult your insurer early in this process to utilize this option! They will send an adjuster to confirm the roof is no longer structurally sound and requires full replacement due to the covered incident. 


How Long Do You Plan to Stay in Your Current Home?

Your intentions as a homeowner also help dictate the best roofing decision. How much longer do you intend to live at that property? 


Roof replacement has clear long-term benefits if you plan to stay ten or more years. Investing in an entirely new roofing system that will last decades makes good sense if you plan to move later on down the line. It will hold up to protect your home for the long haul while also boosting resale value in the future. 


However, if you intend to sell in the next 3-5 years, making strategic repairs may offer enough protection at a lower cost. The main goal is to maintain adequate curb appeal and functionality until you list the house. As long as the repairs blend seamlessly to keep the home dry and attractive, targeting problem spots now can help you defer the sizable investment of full replacement until the next owners tackle this major project. 

Weighing the Benefits of Repairs vs. Replacement

Both roof repairs and replacement provide important protections according to your home's current needs and plans. To make a decision that best aligns with your goals for the property, consider each option's unique pros and cons listed below! 

Pros of Getting Your Roof Repaired

The most obvious advantage of roof repairs vs full replacement is a lower upfront cost to the homeowner. Fixing isolated leaks or damage also means less disruption to your household compared to the major endeavor of installing an entirely fresh roofing system! 

Lower Cost for the Homeowner

Spot repairs will range from a few hundred to a few thousand dollars, depending on how many problem areas require work. Replacing an entire aged roof averages around $10,000, depending on roof size and materials chosen. So, if your roof's issues appear small in scope, repairs can address these targeted weak spots without breaking the bank! Contact reputable local roofers to provide quotes on the specific fixes needed. Their costs should come in significantly less than full replacement from most contractors. 

Less Hassle

Living through a roof replacement can feel like a chaotic, noisy, and dirty renovation project. Debris removal, heavy equipment maneuvering, multiple on-site workers, visible sections of the exposed roof deck, and other invasions make life challenging for at least a few days.


Simple repairs can allow homeowners to address leaks and damage with less daily impact. As long as access to the repair area is straightforward, contractors can complete work neatly and efficiently without dismantling your entire existing roof. The household disturbance remains minimal overall. 


Pros of Getting Your Roof Fully Replaced

Conversely, installing all new roofing materials holds several meaningful advantages over attempting to salvage an aging or severely damaged roof. Read on to explore these benefits! 

Ensure Long-Term Protection and Peace of Mind

When aging shingles and flashings get replaced entirely instead of patched, you safeguard those vulnerable spots around roof penetrations with fresh waterproofing for decades to come. Watertight protection against roof leaks translates to invaluable peace of mind and prevention of roof-related headaches. 

Boost Your Home's Energy-Efficiency

Replacing your roof makes it easy to upgrade the insulation, improve the ventilation of the attic and even choose roofing material that is energy star rated. If your outdated roof lacks modern-day insulation or radiant barriers, a new system can greatly transform your home's energy efficiency. New systems must comply with updated building codes, helping to reflect summer heat and retain interior warmth during the winter. 

Increase Curb Appeal and Value

While roof repairs can be quick, lingering signs of aging roof materials can affect your home's exterior appearance over time. You can increase curb appeal by elevating your property to a gorgeous new roof with eye-catching architectural shingles or colorful accent touches. In turn, boosted aesthetics and protection against leaks will enhance resale value! 

Schedule A FREE Roof Inspection Today!

Don't wait until it's too late - schedule your free estimate and roofing inspection with Simple Solutions today! Call us or send us a message to schedule an appointment and take the first step towards a well maintained roof that will protect your house for years to come.

Roofing Decisions Will Boil Down to Your Unique Property Needs

As explored above, the ideal choice between repair and replacement relies heavily on your roof's current state, budget, and plans for the home in both the short and long term. Roof repairs offer a cost-effective solution when damage remains minor or isolated. But substantial aging, storm impacts, and moisture already invading your attic or walls will necessitate a full roof replacement. This ensures the safety and protection of your family and your property's structure for years to come. 


To best understand the roof issues facing your home and which option makes the most sense, consult the knowledgeable roofing contractors at Simple Solutions! 

Simple Solutions Has Been a Trusted Roofer for Marylanders Since 2016

With thorough evaluations and transparent recommendations tailored to each customer, Simple Solutions is proud to be a trusted roofing company for all your property needs in Maryland! You can find our trucks and roofers all across the state, including:

Top-Rated Residential and Commercial Roofing Services

Our team brings decades of combined experience assessing roof damage across Maryland homes and businesses to determine repair or replacement needs. Licensed, bonded, and insured with strong attention to detail and quality workmanship, Simple Solutions delivers reliable roofing services, whether we're fixing small leaks or tearing off multiple layers of worn shingles to start fresh! 


Contact Our Team Today for a Free Estimate

Unsure if your roof requires minor fixes or if a replacement roof replacement should be on the horizon? Talk to our team of professionals today! We can provide detailed on-site evaluations at no cost and clearly communicate repair versus new roof costs with different material options. Contact Simple Solutions to begin protecting your most valuable asset - your home. Whether we repair today or help you budget for a replacement tomorrow, we have the solutions your property needs long-term! 

bottom of page